On August 12, 2003, the “Notice of the State Council on Promoting the Sustainable and Healthy Development of the Real Estate Market” proposed:
The real estate industry is highly correlated and has strong driving power, and has become a pillar industry of the national economy.
China's real estate at that time would not have imagined that in just over 20 years, its golden age would come to an end.
Especially in 2026, after the downward pressure on the real estate market has persisted for several years, the central government has still introduced a series of policies such as the sale of completed buildings, and the large-scale rescue that many people imagined has not arrived.
The attitude is very clear: even if the economy is under pressure, the principle of “housing is for living, not for speculation” must be adhered to.This is because real estate has indeed tied down too many things in Chinese society, leading to a general lack of happiness and sense of gain in Chinese society. The price increase to destock from 2016 to 2018 had already pushed the bubble to the brink of systemic financial risk, and it is no longer possible to continue to digest the bubble by pushing up the bubble.
However, the economic gap left behind will not be automatically filled. In the first three quarters of 2026, the national real estate development investment was 5.34 trillion yuan, a year-on-year decrease of 20.6%; the area of new housing starts decreased by 24.9%, and this impact was projected onto the entire investment side: in the first three quarters of this year,national fixed asset investment decreased by 7.2% year-on-year, manufacturing investment decreased by 2.1%, and infrastructure investment decreased by 4.2%. China's economy needs new pillars to complete orders, investment, and employment. Who will take over?
In September 2025, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, when explaining the “Work Plan for Stabilizing Growth in the Automotive Industry”, clearly stated that
The automotive industry is a “pillar industry” of the national economy, playing the role of a “ballast stone” for the stable growth of the industrial economy.
It is a consistent practice of the Chinese government that repetitive content has little value, while new statements, new proposals, and these new subjects often represent serious political issues and corresponding government actions.
Let's start with the scale. By 2025, the output value of the automotive industry will account for about 10% of GDP, ranking as the largest pillar industry in the national economy for the second consecutive year, surpassing the real estate industry which has long held the top position. The revenue of the automotive manufacturing industry will reach 11.18 trillion yuan. If automotive maintenance and auto parts are included, the scale of the entire industry chain will be even larger.
Some viewers must be asking,What are the benefits to me, and how does it relate to me, if one industry replaces another?I must say, this is indeed a good thing,There are many potential benefits between the development models of new and old drivers.
First and foremost,Real estate is painful GDP, while automotive GDP can obviously effectively enhance the happiness of the people.
Our society has a very typical critique of the Western economic system, which is that the service industry does not create value and has no increment. You serve me, I serve you. What is the use of inflating GDP?
I think everyone's criticism is a bit like putting on an act for foreigners. The catering industry solves the problem of eating, the medical industry solves the problem of saving lives, the legal industry solves social conflicts and transaction costs, and even the pet service industry, like raising cats and dogs, can provide spiritual sustenance. Services are at least something people are willing to accept and purchase, and they do create incremental value in terms of psychological well-being and convenience in life. How can these things have no value?
In contrast, the GDP generated by real estate is actually very low quality, and does not conform to the strategic needs of high-quality development. To put it bluntly, it's nothing more than residents pre-spending their future labor income through decades of loans, and local governments making a large sum of money from land sales.
For decades in China, real estate has not been consumption nor an industry in the general sense, but merely a financial-fiscal mechanism that extracts labor surplus from the future.
The entire society is still trading low-tech cement, bricks, and land, yet the prices are pushed higher and higher year after year, creating increasingly higher GDP.
This structure has two characteristics. First, it is one-off; residents have limited room to increase leverage and cannot repeat the process indefinitely. Second, housing is a necessity, and rising housing prices inevitably squeeze the living space of the entire society.
The result often leads to the wealth gap between early and late homebuyers, and between homeowners and non-homeowners, being widened by housing prices,, frankly speaking, this goes against the values of socialism which pursues common prosperity and ensures that the fruits of development benefit all people.:
relying on families to bear heavy debts, chasing asset appreciation, and continuously widening the wealth gap between people, this kind ofThe overdraft-type GDP has created a huge amount of social resentment, which cannot even catch up to a single finger of the service industry, let alone the automobile manufacturing industry.
Manufacturing, represented by automobiles, goes a step further than real estate and services, having both numbers and growth. In recent years, we have seen this in the domestic new energy market. New technologies are advancing by leaps and bounds, and every year more new things are offered at various price points, with increasingly higher configurations. A decade ago, configurations that were out of reach for ordinary families are now attainable. Cars are different from mobile phones; mobile phones' performance is eaten away by increasingly bloated software after a few years, but cars are not. Cars have a much longer actual lifespan than mobile phones. Wealthy families can upgrade their cars every two to three years to pursue new experiences, while those with limited budgets can wait a few years to buy used. Technology is disseminated downwards with each update. The actual purchasing power and happiness of the entire society are improving. This in itself is progress.
Second, foreigners don't want houses, but they do want cars.
According to data from the first half of this year, automobile exports reached 5.096 million vehicles, a year-on-year increase of 65.3%; new energy vehicle exports reached 2.355 million vehicles, a year-on-year increase of 1.2 times.
Some people may wonder,Does it matter if foreigners want them or not? Aren't they all sales as long as there are numbers?
Who they are sold to certainly matters, and it matters a lot. What would foreigners do with Chinese houses? Or rather, the number of foreigners who need Chinese houses is an absolute minority. The vast majority of houses are sold to local residents. Taking out a 30-year mortgage, the developer gets the payment, the local government gets land transfer revenue, and the bank gets interest. These things look good. But the currency only circulates internally. Bubbles can only be digested internally. Essentially,it's internal debt and future surplus labor circulating from left hand to right hand. Without transactions in the global market, new resources cannot be exchanged from outside.It's like constantly shooting basketballs, missing, and then grabbing your own rebound, repeating the cycle. The numbers look good, but it's hard to say how much actual effect it has.
More importantly, the debt formed by the current overdraft will have to be repaid in the future. And the process of repaying debt itself is a deleveraging, which will cause downward economic pressure.
Cars are different; they can be sold to obtain real energy, materials, or overseas assets on the global market. This example is particularly evident in Japan. After the Japanese economic collapse, the primary reason Japan was able to maintain the dignity of a developed country was the contribution of its automotive industry. By 2025, Japan still exported approximately 4.17 million new cars from its domestic market, with the export value of automotive-related products reaching 21.9 trillion yen.
These are the thingsOverseas orders support Japanese domestic factories, suppliers, and a large number of jobs. At the same time, they bring back vegetables from Shandong, oil from the Middle East, meat from Australia, and chips from the United States to support the actual consumption of the Japanese people.In recent years, Japan's internal economic pressure is largely due to its declining position in global industrial competition, and the actual living standards of the Japanese people have inevitably faced pressure.
Some people say that China is so large, do we have to rely on global trade? My Great Qing Dynasty has abundant products and lacks nothing, and does not need foreign goods to exchange for necessities. This shows a lack of understanding of the modern economy.
Trade itself can create wealth through comparative advantage and globalization,The same amount of labor, **Through international circulation, it can be exchanged for more goods and services, which is beneficial for the further improvement of ordinary people's living standards. ** This is especially true for a country of 1.4 billion people, given the limitations on total resources.
Finally, there is another benefit: the automotive industry will promote fiscal and tax system reforms in China.
The reason why real estate became a pillar industry back then was not because of any other special characteristics, but because the state monopolized land and could obtain the most monopoly profits through land finance, turning stone into gold.At its peak in 2021, revenue from the transfer of state-owned land use rights was approximately 8.7 trillion yuan, equivalent to 78% of local general public budget revenue for that year.
Moreover, when developers acquire land, the project has not yet generated profits, and the houses have not yet been delivered to ordinary people, but the local government can collect land transfer fees according to the contract. This means that in the entire industry chain, developers bear the roles of financing and investment, and bear the risks of land price declines and debt defaults. Ordinary people, under the long-term pre-sale system, bear the risk of unfinished housing projects. The most profitable segment at the very top of the chain carries no risk.
Working diligently, building supporting facilities, cultivating supply chains, and providing public services, waiting for enterprises to form sustained operating and tax-paying capabilities, and earning money honestly like this must be very boring, right?
Once people make quick money, they are unwilling to earn money diligently, just like the recent crackdown on KTVs in Hangzhou. The displaced workers are not looking for honest jobs, but are trying to find ways to get back into illicit activities.
Many of the chaos seen in the land development sector in the past were due to the sweet taste of quick money through land economic financing, which eventually spiraled out of control.
However, the abnormal growth logic of engaging in real estate is essentially the same as the cost of housing land for young people to settle down and for industrial and economic activities to rent land.The need for local governments to raise funds conflicts with the need to reduce living and operating costs for society and cultivate economic activities that create long-term value.
New energy is a growth industry, and it is precisely an opportunity to pull a large number of local governments away from land finance. We can see that even in the chaotic new energy vehicle market, which is like the Warring States period, local governments have a shadow behind each company to varying degrees.
There are two issues here: first, only a minority can obtain the automotive industry; second, the land finance account, which was entirely local before, is now shared with the central government for value-added tax from the automotive industry chain.
This will bring the contradiction of mismatched powers and responsibilities between the central and local governments, and between different local governments, back to the surface.Simultaneously advancing the relocation of consumption tax collection, the reconstruction of the local tax system, and the optimization of transfer payments are things that must be discussed and done.
Finance can temporarily deviate from the track, with large-scale demolition, construction, and project initiation, leading to a mess in the end. But in the long run, a government's growth logic will inevitably normalize, returning to industry and economic growth itself, which is a good thing.
章北海的自然选择
Après moi, le déluge

Long press the QR code to scan and follow
Click to read the original text and follow directly



